Bolshoi Ballet's Nina Kaptsova and Mikhail Lobukhin in "Spartacus." Photo by Elena Fetisova, Courtesy Bolshoi Ballet.

Do Ballets Have a Life Span?

If you were a subscriber to a respectable repertory theater company, you would never tolerate a diet of lustful Saracen princes, troops of tots running around in blackface, upstart Roman slaves versed in Karl Marx, dark-skinned serving girls with bejeweled navels and superwomen who destroy any man passing their way.

Ballet lovers, however, are more tolerant, too much for my taste. For a few minutes of vivid, occasionally masterful choreography, the devotees of Terpsichore are willing to put up with nonsensical, dated or offensive librettos, and they lose their qualms (if they entered the theater with any) in a flood of tours jetés and grandes pirouettes à la seconde.

Face the fact: Many of the ballets that audiences cherish today have simply aged out. The reasons are both political and social, and the dances that have not adapted to espousing contemporary values somehow look like stale period pieces.


So let's take a stroll through the repertoires of the world's major ballet companies. The certified classics—Sleeping Beauty, Swan Lake, Nutcracker and Giselle—survive in some manner relatively unscathed, possibly because they have remained in the repertoire for most of the past century, and have been adjusted by each new generation that confronts the material. Even here, you can find dissenters. Years ago in an interview with Mats Ek, the acclaimed Swedish choreographer surprised me by expressing his distaste for The Sleeping Beauty, because, for him, the libretto's value system extols the ruling hierarchy. Some might argue that Nutcracker possesses racist elements, with its pointed-finger Chinese dance and slithery Arabian number.

Viktoria Tereshkina and artists of the Mariinsky Ballet in "Raymonda." Photo by Natalia Razina, Courtesy Segerstrom Center for the Performing Arts.

But then we come to all those relics, mostly from 19th-century Russia. They share a passion for national and religious stereotyping, which should be unacceptable today. Take American Ballet Theatre's Le Corsaire, which, after its revival some years ago, maintains its hold on today's repertoire. The ballet was first staged in France, then it traveled to Russia and the West. The ABT version, containing bits of its predecessors, portrays Turks as slave keepers, and what is even more ignoble, in this fantasy world—Muslims.

Sometime, two centuries ago, adherents of Islam became the most dependable ballet villains. In Raymonda, Abderakhman is not just a believer in Islam (which the 19th-century arts associated with sexual potency), he is aggressively seeking the hand of the pure Christian heroine. That is enough to make him the bad guy. Often, in performances of Raymonda, our response is complicated by the fact that Abderakhman gets the most exciting choreography.

Then, we arrive at La Bayadère, which sums up the era's ambivalent attitude towards Eastern religions. Except for the wonderfully mind-bending “Kingdom of the Shades" act, this Petipa work was unknown in this country until Natalia Makarova staged the complete version opulently for ABT in 1980, then re-created it all over the globe. The principal baddie is a Brahmin high priest, who hungers after temple dancer Nikiya. But the pseudo-Indian dances, filtered through Russian sensibilities, can also be culturally offensive.

If it's any consolation, Rudolf Nureyev's staging of La Bayadère for the Paris Opéra Ballet, with its array of fake skin tones, is even more racially troublesome. Fortunately, the imperishable “Shades" scene, by itself, has entered the repertoire of several major American companies.

Blatant propaganda is another factor that makes ballet age faster than a week-old croissant, and much of it has come from Soviet Russia. Most recent settings of Romeo and Juliet (notably Sir Kenneth MacMillan's) have derived, in some way, from Leonid Lavrovsky's 1940 version of the Shakespeare play. The original wears its political biases with cape-swirling aplomb. The last time I saw this Romeo and Juliet I was a bit shocked. Even after the fall of the Soviet Union, the company had retained the first-act marketplace episode, in which the slimy aristocrat Tybalt kicks a bunch of poor beggars. The moment is irrelevant to the narrative, but back in the '30s, the episode probably pleased some hack commissar.

However, the master of Soviet propaganda kitsch remains Yury Grigorovich, the choreographer of that raucous 1968 extravaganza Spartacus, with its pounding Khachaturian score. A generation ago, when Bolshoi Ballet visits to America were increasing, we would laugh at the overheated marches, the wiggly dances of the evil Aegina and the crucifixion of Spartacus, while admiring the performances of phenomena like Maris Liepa and the unforgettable Nina Timofeyeva. But their time has passed, and in the era of perestroika, so has the equating of Roman slaves with the Soviet proletariat. Spartacus has not transcended its era.

American Ballet Theatre in a 1973 production of Agnes de Mille's "Rodeo." Photo Courtesy Dance Magazine Archives.

Then, there's that category of works of undoubted artistry, which find themselves at odds with contemporary social customs and standards. Age has simply overtaken them. I hesitated to include Agnes de Mille's 1942 Rodeo, because it was a landmark in American ballet and because of Aaron Copland's rousing score. But feminism has flourished in 2016 America. It is difficult to get excited about a young woman who wants to be both a cowgirl and an object of male desire in an era when Iowa has elected for U.S. Senator the hog-tying Joni Ernst. I'm not alone in my reassessment of the de Mille. The other year, the great millennial dancemaker Justin Peck jettisoned the Rodeo libretto, retained the Copland music and produced an acclaimed ballet.

Fresh take: NYCB dancers in Justin Peck's "Rodeo: Four Dance Episodes." Photo by Paul Kolnik, Courtesy NYCB.

Speaking of changing gender standards and expectations, it has become increasingly difficult to swallow the dyspeptic, anti-feminist tone of Jerome Robbins' The Cage, where an insect woman destroys all men who cross her path. Sixty-five years after its premiere, it seems sour and unforgiving, one of the great choreographer's pieces that should disappear into the dance history books.

What should keep ballet fresh, young and relevant is historical reassessment, a return to the source, a reconsideration of the social values in which a ballet emerged and a canny fusion with our contemporary values and standards. Yes, I am talking about Alexei Ratmansky. He transformed a propaganda show like The Bright Stream into a warm, humane farce, and he continues to reimagine the standard dance repertoire. It can be done. Look to Ratmansky for more ageless experiences on the ballet stage.

Old also meets new brilliantly in Sir Frederick Ashton's 1960 comic masterpiece, La Fille mal gardée. Ashton turned a rustic 1789 French tale into a timeless survey of life and love in the French (really English) countryside. He started with all the stock figures of classic farce (young lovers, disapproving mother, village simpleton, etc.) and imbued all of them with such humanity that La Fille will never date. The characters exude internal life and that should keep them fresh forever.

Latest Posts


Peter Mueller, Courtesy Cincinnati Ballet

2020 Stars of the Corps: 10 Dancers Making Strides In and Out of the Spotlight

The corps de ballet make up the backbone of every company. In our Fall 2020 issue, we highlighted 10 ensemble standouts to keep your eye on. Click on their names to learn more!

Dara Holmes, Joffrey Ballet

A male dancer catches a female dancer in his right arm as she wraps her left arm around his shoulder and executes a high arabesque on pointe. Both wear white costumes and dance in front of a blue backdrop onstage.

Dara Holmes and Edson Barbosa in Myles Thatcher's Body of Your Dreams

Cheryl Mann, Courtesy Joffrey Ballet

Wanyue Qiao, American Ballet Theatre

Wearing a powder blue tutu, cropped light yellow top and feather tiara, Wanyue Qiao does a piqu\u00e9 retir\u00e9 on pointe on her left leg and pulls her right arm in towards her.

Wanyue Qiao as an Odalisque in Konstantin Sergeyev's Le Corsaire

Gene Schiavone, Courtesy ABT

Joshua Guillemot-Rodgerson, Houston Ballet

Three male dancers in tight-fitting, multicolored costumes stand in positions of ascending height from left to right. All extend their right arms out in front of them.

Joshua Guillemot-Rodgerson (far right) with Saul Newport and Austen Acevedo in Oliver Halkowich's Following

Amitava Sarkar, Courtesy Houston Ballet

Leah McFadden, Colorado Ballet

Wearing a white pixie wig and a short light-pink tunic costume, a female ballet dancer poses in attitude front on pointe with her left arm bent across her ribs and her right hand held below her chin.

Leah McFadden as Amour in Colorado Ballet's production of Don Quixote

Mike Watson, Courtesy Colorado Ballet

Maria Coelho, Tulsa Ballet

Maria Coelho and Sasha Chernjavsky in Andy Blankenbuehler's Remember Our Song

Kate Lubar, Courtesy Tulsa Ballet

Alexander Reneff-Olson, San Francisco Ballet

A ballerina in a black feathered tutu stands triumphantly in sous-sus, holding the hand of a male dancer in a dark cloak with feathers underneath who raises his left hand in the air.

Alexander Reneff-Olson (right) as Von Rothbart with San Francisco Ballet principal Yuan Yuan Tan in Swan Lake

Erik Tomasson, Courtesy SFB

India Bradley, New York City Ballet

Wearing a blue dance dress with rhinestone embellishments and a sparkly tiara, India Bradley finishes a move with her arms out to the side and hands slightly flexed.

India Bradley practices backstage before a performance of Balanchine's Tschaikovsky Piano Concerto No. 2.

Erin Baiano, Courtesy NYCB

Bella Ureta, Cincinnati Ballet

Wearing a white dress with pink corset, Bella Ureta does a first arabesque on pointe in front of an onstage stone wall.

Bella Ureta performs the Act I Pas de Trois in Kirk Peterson's Swan Lake

Hiromi Platt, Courtesy Cincinnati Ballet

Alejándro Gonzales, Oklahoma City Ballet

Dressed in a green bell-boy costume and hat, Alejandro Gonz\u00e1lez does a saut\u00e9 with his left leg in retir\u00e9 and his arms in a long diagonal from right to left. Other dancers in late 19-century period costumes watch him around the stage.

Alejandro González in Michael Pink's Dracula at Oklahoma City Ballet.

Kate Luber, Courtesy Oklahoma City Ballet

Nina Fernandes, Miami City Ballet

Wearing a long white tutu and crown, Nina Fernandes does a saut de chat in front of a wintery backdrop as snow falls from the top of the stage.

Nina Fernandes in George Balanchine's The Nutcracker

Alexander Iziliaev, Courtesy Miami City Ballet

Quinn Wharton

Pacific Northwest Ballet's Angelica Generosa Shares Her Classic, Comfy Style In and Out of the Studio

"I love the feeling and look of effortless fashion," says Angelica Generosa. Preferring a classic style, the Pacific Northwest Ballet soloist keeps her wardrobe stocked with blazers. But they serve a practical purpose, too. "It tends to get chilly in Seattle, so it's the perfect accessory for layering," Generosa explains.

She's also quite fond of designer handbags. "They're my go-to accessory, and they're also my weakness when shopping," she says, naming Chloé, Chanel and Dior as some of her favorite brands. "I really appreciate the craftsmanship it takes to produce one—they're so beautiful and each has its own story, in a way."

In the studio, Generosa prioritizes comfort, and she'll change up her look depending on the repertoire (leotards and tutus for classical works, breathable shirts with workout pants for contemporary). But she always arrives to work in style. "I really love putting together outfits for even just going to the studio," she says. "It's another way of expressing my mood and what kind of vibe I'm going for that day."

The Details: Street

Angelica Generosa, wearing a blue blazer, white blouse and gray jeans, is photographed from underneath as she walks and looks to the right.

Quinn Wharton

BCBG blazer: "It has some shoulder pads and a really cool pattern," says Generosa. "It reminds me of my mom and '80s fashion."

Zara blouse: She incorporate neutrals, like this white satin button-up, to balance bright pops of colors.

Angelica Generosa looks off to her right in front of a glass-windowed building. She wears a blue blazer, white blouse, gray jeans and carries a small green handbag.

Quinn Wharton

Madewell jeans: Comfort is a major factor for Generosa, who gets her fashion inspiration from her mom, friends and people she comes across day to day.

Chloé bag: "I tend to have smaller purses because I'm quite small. Bigger bags overwhelm me sometimes—unless it's my dance bag, of course!"

The Details: Studio

Angleica Generosa, wearing a blue tank leotard, black wool leggings and pink pointe shoes, balances in a lunge on pointe with her left leg in front, facing a wall of windows.

Quinn Wharton

Label Dancewear leotard: "This was designed by my good friend Elizabeth Murphy, a principal dancer here at PNB. Her leotards always fit me really well."

Mirella leggings: "I get cold easily," says Generosa, who wears leggings and vests to stay warm throughout the day.

Angelica Generosa, wearing a blue tank leotard, black wool tights and pink pointe shoes, jumps and crosses her right foot over her left shin while lifting her arms up to the right.

Quinn Wharton

Freed of London pointe shoes: "When sewing them, I crisscross my elastics and use an elasticized ribbon from Body Wrappers," which helps alleviate Achilles tendon issues, she says. She then trims the satin off of the tip of the shoe. "Then I bend the shank a bit to loosen it up and cut a bit off where my arch is."

Getty Images

This New "Nutcracker" Competition Wants Your Dance Studio to be Part of a Virtual Collaboration

Despite worldwide theater closures, the Universal Ballet Competition is keeping The Nutcracker tradition alive in 2020 with an online international competition. The event culminates in a streamed, full-length video of The Virtual Nutcracker consisting of winning entries on December 19. The competition is calling on studios, as well as dancers of all ages and levels, to submit videos by November 29 to be considered.

"Nutcracker is a tradition that is ingrained in our hearts," says UBC co-founder Lissette Salgado-Lucas, a former dancer with Royal Winnipeg Ballet and Joffrey Ballet. "We danced it for so long as professionals, we can't wait to pass it along to dancers through this competition."

Keep reading SHOW LESS

Editors' Picks